|  |
| Customer Reviews: | | Average Customer Review: ( 54 customer reviews )
Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
69 of 70 found the following review helpful:
 A Few Facts, Lots of Speculation and Worlds of Wonder Feb 13, 2006
By John A Lee III
"jal3"
Nobody should confuse this with a course of paleontology. Nobody should even confuse this with a broad survey of the subject. Instead, it is a magnificent flight of imagination based upon some real science but which does not let the science take precedence over the wonder. It is wonderful
This is a series of three programs. Each deals with prehistoric life before the advent of the dinosaurs.
In the first program, we are treated to one theory of the formation of our planet and introduced to the Cambrian seas. There are not dinosaurs here. Fish barely even exist. That does not stop the cycle of predation in a world of gigantic marine scorpions and the proto-fish prey. We see the colonization of the land by the first plants and encounter the first amphibians, learning a little bit about the evolutionary pressures that drove their emergence. The program ends with the first true reptiles and the hard shelled egg.
The second episode takes place more on land. Gigantic arthropods contest with gigantic amphibians and the odd reptile here and there. We see the first strains of reptile that will eventually give rise to the mammals. Life is still a contest of the predator and the prey.
The third episode advances the story through the lives of some early, pre-dinosaur reptiles. The motif of eat and be eaten is still the rule of the day. The episode ends with the apprearance of true dinosaurs, where the series first began.
There is a lot of speculation in this work. Some of it is well reasoned and logical. Some of it is much less so. Only a few species are looked at with any degree of detail. The great Devonian age of the fishes is bypassed in a short sentence. That does not stop the wonder of it all. It is fascinating seeing the fossils come to life even with the speculations.
The DVD also includes a "making of" segment which covers all three of the series. It too is worth watching.
This will never replace real coursework and has all of the depth of the old, "Mutual of Omaha Wild Kingdom" but neither was ever intended to teach zoology. Both were meant to kindle a sense of wonder. Both accomplish that end.
21 of 23 found the following review helpful:
 Putting meat on the bones... Feb 17, 2006
By Michael Valdivielso
Three episodes that explore the life, or what life might have been like, before the dinosaurs showed up onto the stage. With only about 90 minutes that does seem to leave a lot of details out but most of the major turning points are hit on - animals and plants moving from the oceans to the land, the development of certain organs for survival, evolution working to make animals and plants more fit. Sea scorpions, giant spiders and killer fish that could take on sharks make me happy I live NOW and not back then.
The DVD extra, the Trilogy of Life, talks about the history of the THREE shows, Walking with Dinosaurs, Walking with Beasts and Walking with Monsters to show how the first series produced the next and so on.
I really enjoyed this series and wanted more - I think dinosaurs get too much of the spotlight and would like to know more about life before and after them.
13 of 14 found the following review helpful:
great...but could have been much better Apr 02, 2006
this special was amazing. i am really 16, and have always been a fan of creatures from before dinosaur supremacy. however, i think 90 minutes is far too short for such a huge amount of life. most of the time periods up until the early Permian were skimmed over, and the Ordovician period was completely passed over, without a word said.
also, there were many creatures that i was disapointed not to see get re-created in this special. a few apperences, such as Gorgonops, Dimetrodon, Edaphosaurus, Euparkeria, Pterygotus, etc, i was happy to see. however, i was dissapointed when i did not see Icthyostega, Estemmenosuchus, Protorosaurus(earliest known archosaur), and many more creatures that i would like to know more about.
it is good, for 90 minutes, but if the creators were to re-create it as a four hour special, it could become something truly spectacular.
21 of 25 found the following review helpful:
 Interesting Apr 08, 2006
By Nick Spreitzer
Seems that Tim Haines and BBC decided to follow in George Lucas' footsteps. Making what would be best accepted by the public first, then completing the series later with the more controversial stuff (if Lucas had made the Phantom Menace first, no one would know what Star Wars is today - the story is far too complicated).
Walking With Dinosaus and Prehistoric Beasts were both quite good, except the narration by Kenneth Branaugh, who seemed like he could care aless about what he was talking about and give the impression that these animals were failures (which they were not!) There are some things about the series that I didn't like, mostly the animatronics and some facts, nitpicking stuff.
Walking With Monsters, in my humble oppinion is the least strong of the series for the following reasons. 1: It was too short. 2: The animals didn't act as naturalistically as they did in the others (spiders don't stab and stab their prey like a human murderer, they jab and then wait for their poison to take affect). 3: It seemed rushed - sequences that should have taken 30 minutes took half that.
Despite these fallbacks, the CG is quite good, animatronics was used VERY sparingly and the Dimetrodon sequence is GREAT! It was my favorite of all of them. I would recommend this DVD just to complete the Walking With story. If you want more on PreDinosaurs, go for The Shape of Life DVD set. It's GREAT. So, on it's own, Walking With Monsters is a waste of time (in my oppinion), but with Walking With Dinosaurs and Prehistoric Beasts, it works fairly well. And despite all the series' fallbacks, everyone should have the complete series in their collection.
Other Great Dino Series: When Dinosaurs Roamed America, WWD: Chased By Dinosaurs, Dinosaur Planet. Hope this was informative, thanks for listening (or reading more like).
8 of 8 found the following review helpful:
 Random bits of science at best Jun 27, 2007
By Rob Martin
"Ichthyopaleo doc"
This could have been a truly wonderful experience, but it falls quite short of the rest of the series. The animations are still good, and it's wonderful to see all of these reconstructions (even when artistic licenses are invoked), but there are many parts that may mislead the casual viewer.
The video starts will the collision of a large bolide that led to the formation of the moon, and then we jump to the Cambrian and . If you are interested in geobiology, early plants or other invertebrates of the early oceans, don't even pick this video up; they are mentioned in passing if at all. Okay, so I guess we are talking about `monsters' and , not microbes, the first plants or other inverts, was the monster of the time, but the video moves on to , hardly a monster. Granted, eurypterids are covered, but the chronology of their evolution becomes quite confusing. Now, I am expecting some of the true monsters of the late Paleozoic; , xenacanthid sharks, , etc. Instead we leap ahead to and the land invasion of the amphibians ( is shown, but never mentioned by name). Suddenly, we are in a landscape (how about that amniote egg?--why not convey its importance?). Here is where a lot of speculation stretches the limits of reason. Apparently, though there is no evidence of it, baby pelycosaurs would cover themselves in dung to escape the cannibalistic adults. Funny, but I never came across anything like that in any of my paleoecology work... Later, the video implies that the eggs hatch in mere hours! Of course, there is a segue at the end leading us toward the dinosaurs, but there is no mention of the Permian extinction, or any extinction for that matter, and its causes!
I was reluctant to give this video three stars; the reconstructions are cool enough to warrant 2.5. Since I couldn't record such a score, I was forced, based primarily on the glaring omissions, extreme exaggerations and lack of continuity, to drop it down to two stars. If you own the other "Walking with..." videos, you will obviously want this video. If you are a paleontology minded person, you will enjoy seeing these fossils come to life. If you are a casual science fan, keep in mind that you are seeing only a very small and very random part of the picture. Less time should have been spent with creating a "Crocodile Hunter"-like program, and more time should have been spent showing how these monsters came about and why they are no longer around.
See all 54 customer reviews on Amazon.com
|
| | |
